Regulatory Capture at HMRC?

Is the story of HMRCs failure to collect the right amount of tax from some big businesses an example of regulatory capture? In the current example, the Public Accounts Committee has said that HM Revenue and Customs enjoyed an “unduly cosy” relationship with major companies, and their procedures have allowed rules to be ‘bent’ so that up to £25bn tax has been underpaid. Regulatory capture (an example of government failure) is what happens when regulated industries are able to gain influence over their regulator, so that instead of serving the public interest, the regulator actually supports the interest of the industry concerned. In this case, there does not seem to be one specific industry concerned (although Goldman Sachs’s underpayment of something between £8mn and £20mn comes in for particular criticism); however the situation does seem to meet the requirements defined by the Economist as “Gamekeeper turns poacher or, at least, helps poacher”.

More on the story here: Taxman slammed over ‘cosy’ business relations Goldman Sachs tax deal faces UK legal challenge