Inheritance Tax Reform: Revenue Raiser or a Wealth Redistribution Tool?

Recent speculation about changes to inheritance tax (IHT) in the UK has sparked a significant debate on how best to balance revenue generation with fairness. Inheritance tax in the UK is charged at 40% on estates exceeding £325,000, a threshold unchanged since 2009. This static threshold, combined with rising property values, has expanded the scope of IHT, pulling in more estates than ever before—a phenomenon known as fiscal drag. As the government looks for ways to raise revenue, tightening IHT rules seems like a likely avenue.

Analysis and Evaluation

The Role of Fiscal Drag

The concept of fiscal drag is crucial in understanding the increasing burden of IHT. With the tax-free threshold frozen for over a decade, inflation and rising asset prices mean more estates are liable for IHT. This phenomenon can be seen in the 4% rise in IHT liabilities to £6bn, despite only 4.4% of UK deaths resulting in an IHT bill. This suggests that more middle-class families, rather than the ultra-wealthy, are increasingly affected by this tax.

Potential Reforms and Their Implications

1. Adjusting the Tax-Free Threshold and Rates: One straightforward method to increase IHT revenue would be to lower the tax-free threshold or increase the tax rate. However, such changes could disproportionately affect those with modest estates, intensifying public dissatisfaction and potentially stifling incentives to save and invest.
2. Limiting Reliefs: Current reliefs, such as agricultural property relief and business relief, allow significant portions of wealth to be transferred without IHT. Tightening these reliefs could raise considerable revenue. For instance, in 2021-2022, these reliefs accounted for £4.4bn in exemptions. However, reducing these reliefs could adversely affect family-owned farms and small businesses, which often rely on these exemptions to stay viable after the owner's death.
3. Reforming Other Taxes: Besides IHT, the government is also considering reforms in capital gains tax and council tax. Capital gains tax could see reduced exemptions, increasing the tax burden on profits from asset sales. Reforming council tax to reflect current property values rather than outdated bands could also provide a fairer system, aligning tax payments more closely with property values.

Wealth Redistribution and Intergenerational Equity

A leaked recording hinted at using IHT as a tool for wealth redistribution and addressing intergenerational inequality. The idea is to redistribute wealth from richer to poorer families and ensure that the burden of taxation is more equitably shared. While this is a noble goal, it is crucial to balance such measures with incentives for wealth creation and economic growth. Overly punitive taxes on inheritance could discourage investment and saving, potentially harming the economy.

Exam-Style Questions for Discussion

1. Discuss the economic implications of fiscal drag on inheritance tax revenue. How does this affect middle-class families in the UK?
2. Evaluate the potential impacts of lowering the inheritance tax threshold on wealth distribution and economic growth.
3. How might tightening agricultural property relief and business relief affect family-owned businesses and farms?
4. Consider the argument that inheritance tax could be used as a tool for wealth redistribution. What are the potential benefits and drawbacks of this approach?
5. Discuss the merits and challenges of reforming the council tax system to reflect current property values.

Glossary of Key Economic Terms

• Capital Gains Tax: A tax on the profit from the sale of assets or investments.
• Council Tax: A local tax on property in the UK, based on the value of the property.
• Fiscal Drag: The effect of inflation and economic growth pushing taxpayers into higher tax brackets, increasing tax revenue without changes in tax rates.
• Inheritance Tax (IHT): A tax on the estate (property, money, and possessions) of someone who has died.
• Reliefs: Reductions in the amount of tax payable, often used to incentivize certain behaviours or support specific groups, such as businesses or farmers.

Read more here from Sky News