Essential update: differences between Labour and the Conservatives
Can’t put a cigarette paper between them?
Whilst we are awaiting the outcome of series of Labour internal policy reviews by their new leader, Ed Miliband, we can still identify post election differences between the parties on issues from the economy to civil liberties
Here is an overview of some of those I have identified in recent months.
The economy. Government and opposition have clashed on the cause of the deficit, and the best way to tackle it. The Conservatives have blamed their Labour predecessors for allowing private debt to grow and for the state over reaching itself. Labour have opposed Osborne’s spending review, arguing that cuts should be delayed and take place over a longer time period.
Public services. Plans to devolve power to GPs have been described as a “dangerous experiment”, at a time when public spending is being tightened. In education, Labour have been highly critical of the idea of “free schools”. Labour also opposed: ending EMA payments to 16-18 years olds; proposals to allow universities to raise tuition fees to £9,000; cuts to school sports funding; Gove’s education white paper.
Welfare reform. Labour have been less than enthusiastic about the Con-Lib government’s plans for welfare reforms: changes to child benefit have been described by Ed Miliband as “unworkable”; the 10% cut in housing benefit is, according to Douglas Alexander, “unfair”; replacing the tax credits system, and the elimination of the child trust fund, will, according to Labour, increase poverty.
Crime. Teresa May announced that the government was to scrap ASBOs (a decision criticised by Labour), and Labour have said that plans to cut the number of front line policemen will have a detrimental effect on crime reduction.
Civil liberties. ID cards have been kicked into the long grass, as has the national identity register. Government plans are in progress to ensure DNA storage and CCTV camera use will be more tightly regulated, and the Conservatives have stuck to commitments to a review of a host of other measures that were a feature of the 1997-2010 Labour governments, such as local authority surveillance powers.
The EU. Under the European Union bill, the Tories plan to bind future governments to holding a referendum before any further “significant” powers are transferred to Brussels.
As an extentsion exercise you could research the background to any of these policies by typing in the name of the policy into a search engine followed by “Labour” or “Labour reaction”. Why do Labour oppose the planned trebling of tuition fees, for instance? And how can the government justify scrapping the EMA?
You can also keep up-to-date with the coalition’s progress via the excellent pledge tracker on the Guardian website. See here.
blog comments powered by Disqus
Revision Update: UK Politics: Labour as a One-Nation Party? [16 May 2013]
Revision Update: The Executive: Prime Ministerial Power [14 May 2013]
Revision Update: The Executive: Coalition: All Good Things Must Come to an End [14 May 2013]
AS parties: divide over energy prices [19 Oct 2011]
The Coalition and the Conservatives [9 Oct 2011]
Politics on YouTube: political history repeating itself? [28 Sep 2011]
UK political parties: the Tory Party’s European problem [19 Sep 2011]
Coalition collapse? [1 Jul 2011]
President Cameron [22 Jun 2011]
Unit 2 PM/Cab examples [10 May 2011]
AS (and UK Issues) Politics update: Labour opposition to Tory education policy [15 Dec 2010]
AS politics: election systems update [5 Dec 2010]
Power in the central executive territory [16 Oct 2010]
Prime Ministers are not like you and me [14 Oct 2010]
What Does Ed Miliband’s Victory Tell Us About Modern British Political Leadership? [26 Sep 2010]
Labour leadership campaign - who are you closest to? [1 Sep 2010]
Great resource on Con-Lib coalition so far [2 Aug 2010]
Full Cabinet graphic [18 May 2010]
UK political parties exam update - part one [8 Apr 2010]
Student Challenge - make their own Cameron poster [21 Jan 2010]
Tories: defining times? [3 Oct 2009]
Labour pains [27 Sep 2009]
Let battle commence [18 Sep 2009]
The battle over spending [15 Sep 2009]
Brown v Cameron [2 Jul 2009]
It’s the economy, stupid! [1 Jul 2009]
AS Revision: Constitutional Reform [26 May 2009]
Electing and connecting [25 May 2009]
Gordomania? [12 Mar 2009]
Bullingdon Club antics don’t look too good in a recession [26 Oct 2008]
Wipeout! [21 Sep 2008]
Join our Politics Teacher Resource Newsletter
